Whakapapa Stories

The Fire on the Beach

The day they buried old Captain Huntley at Tahuahua, in Queen Charlotte Sound, his youngest son burnt his father's papers on the beach. That's how my great-aunt Phoebe told it. In less than a month that boy had lost his sister, his mother, his nephew and his father.

THE FIRE ON THE BEACH

As a small child, Annie Woodgate's daughter Jean was sent over to her gran's at Tahuahua with her brothers and sisters. She remembered a short, stout gran with very, very curly hair, in a feathered cloak. The house was a raupō whare, built of the swamp bulrush, with feathered cloaks on the floor to sleep in.

When her husband was coming up the Sound in his sailing boat, Jean said, her gran used to speak over the water to stop it being rough.

Jean told her friend Gwen Matthews, and Mike Taylor of the Picton Museum kept it in his paper.

Her gran was Elizabeth Huntley, known as Peti. The man in the sailing boat was Captain Charles Huntley. They're my great-great-grandparents.

Peti was the daughter of John McDonald, a whaler, and Takaroa Makutu. Mike Taylor's paper says he was the first Pākehā to settle at Waitohi, where Picton is now. Peti's first husband had been Harry Aldridge, a son of the old whaler at Ocean Bay.

Tahuahua is Blackwood Bay, about eleven miles from Picton by boat. In 1911 it had a few families and a school, built the year before. Peti's daughter Annie lived there with her husband Tom Woodgate and a houseful of children. Her son William was there too, with his wife Hariata and their little ones.

The water was the road, and it could turn on you. One January night in 1905 two of the Huntley sons sailed out of Picton about ten, with stores for home. Their boat was found upside down off Dieffenbach, where the paper said the water was known for being choppy. They swam for over half an hour to reach the shore. The stores were lost.

Mum copied out by hand what D. M. Furness wrote about October 1911 in Tahuahua: The Story of Blackwood Bay. The book calls it "the black month".

Early in October Annie had her eleventh child at home in the bay, a baby girl, Agnes Hannah, known as Mona. Annie was weak after the birth. Then she took pneumonia.

They got her to Picton, to the hospital. She died there on the Tuesday morning. She was thirty-eight. Two days later the Marlborough Express said she left "a husband and eleven children, the youngest being only five days old."

Peti had probably been with her daughter at the birth. She caught it too. Four days after Annie, she died at home. She was never taken to hospital.

The next week it was Annie's eldest boy, Thomas. He was eighteen. Acute pneumonia, at Picton hospital.

Then the Captain. In eleven days he had lost his daughter, then his wife, then his grandson. Eight days after Thomas he was gone too. The cause was written down as influenza pneumonia.

Four of one family in nineteen days. They were buried at Tahuahua, close to home.

That November a letter from the bay told the Education Board there had been another death, and that three children of another family were in the hospital.

There were no antibiotics. The official count for New Zealand that year was 522 deaths from pneumonia. Penicillin wasn't used in a New Zealand hospital until 1944.

Then they buried the Captain.

Auntie Phoebe was William's daughter, my grandfather Ossie's sister. Mum drove from Picton to Motueka with family and spent the day with her, with an old cassette recorder. Mum wrote it up for our reunion book: "The day Charles was buried, his youngest son Alan burnt all his records, photos and certificates, on the beach."

Nobody wrote down why.

If you've ever gone looking for your own people and wondered why there's so little paper, that fire is one answer in ours.

Auntie Phoebe had her own memory of the same boy. When her parents and grandparents were down with the flu, her Uncle Allan looked after her and her brother Donald. She remembered sitting in a dinghy with Donald while Allan rowed them to Blackwood Bay.

Allan didn't get long either. The next September he was brought up to Picton with rheumatic fever, and he died in the hospital there. He was twenty.

Phoebe once asked her father if her Granny had been a little woman with dark curly hair. He couldn't believe she remembered. She was only a toddler when Charles and Elizabeth died. It had always been in the back of her mind.

Peti's son William married Hariata, one of the four women behind the Bledisloe chair. Their son Ossie, the shark man of Fishing Bay, was my grandfather.

Eighty-one years later, in 1992, the Huntley reunion unveiled two headstones for Charles and Elizabeth Huntley at the urupā at Waikawa. One stayed there. The other was taken by waka to Blackwood Bay on the reunion weekend. One photo in our reunion book shows it roped into a frame in a waka out on the water. In another, men in gumboots carry it between them, with the bush at their backs.

That same year Mum wrote our whakapapa out by hand. Sixty feet of it, names all the way back.

A boy burnt the papers on a beach in 1911. His brother's granddaughter put the family back on paper.

Not all of this is proved yet. All four deaths that October are in the official death index, and Annie's is in the paper too. I haven't read the certificates. The fire is how Auntie Phoebe told it. The dinghy and her Granny are her own memories, and the cloak and the water are Jean's. Phoebe's page spells him Alan.

There's no known photo of Peti or the Captain. If you have one, or a photo of Tahuahua in their time, or any paper that missed the fire, I'd really like to see it.

Sources are in the comments.

A black and white view through dark tree branches, across the water to the Picton Hospital buildings on a hillside. Written on the plate: Picton Hospital from Domain.
Picton Hospital from the Domain, in a photograph catalogued as 1911, the year Annie Woodgate died there. Photo by Frederick George Radcliffe. Auckland Libraries Heritage Collections 35-R1103

Open full image

A black and white view across the water to a bay under steep bush-covered hills, with a house and a boatshed on the shore and handwriting along the edge of the negative.
Tahuahua, Blackwood Bay, in November 1957, 46 years after this story. Swanson's in Blackwood Bay, Queen Charlotte Sound, 24 November 1957, by Leslie Adkin. Te Papa (A.008669)

Open full image

A black and white photograph of a small raupō house with a thatched roof, part of it fallen in, and trees behind it.
A raupō whare at Wairau Pā in Marlborough, about the 1880s. Jean remembered her gran's house at Tahuahua as a raupō whare. This is a different whare, shown as an example. Raupo whare at Wairau Pa. Chaytor, Isabel Clervaux, 1890-1976 :Chaytor family photographs. Ref: 1/2-049920-F. Alexander Turnbull Library, Wellington, New Zealand. https://natlib.govt.nz/records/23102021

Open full image

A colour view from a bush-covered hill over a sheltered blue inlet, with green hills on both sides and flax in front.
Looking out from a hill across Tahuahua, Blackwood Bay, in December 2021. Photo: Powellelli, CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), via Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:TahuahuaBay.jpg). Location data removed from our copy. The picture itself is unchanged.

Open full image

A colour photograph of a dark plaque fixed to a rough black rock on a white base, with grass and a stone wall behind. The plaque reads: In Memory Of Charles and Elizabeth Huntley, 1845 to 1911 and 1849 to 1911, And their descendants Aldridge and Woodgate Families, Buried at Blackwood Bay (Tahuahua), Erected by Committee Members of Huntley Reunion 1992.
The 1992 plaque for Charles and Elizabeth Huntley, set in a rock. It says they're buried at Blackwood Bay (Tahuahua). Two headstones were unveiled at the Waikawa urupā. One stayed there, and the other was taken by waka to Blackwood Bay on the weekend of the 1992 reunion. Photo: family collection

Open full image

A colour photograph of a plaque for Charles and Elizabeth Huntley on a square concrete base, tied down with blue rope, in a boat on green water with two wooden oars beside it.
The second 1992 plaque for Charles and Elizabeth Huntley, tied down with blue rope on its concrete base, with oars alongside. This is the one that was taken by waka to Blackwood Bay. Photo: family collection

Open full image

A colour photograph of a long waka with a carved stern post, full of paddlers with paddles raised, a small yellow boat beside it, and bush-covered hills behind.
The waka out on the water at the 1992 reunion, full of paddlers, with a small boat alongside. Photo: family collection

Open full image

A black and white photograph of seven men, several in gumboots, carrying a heavy stone slab between them on a gravel bank, with bush behind.
Men in gumboots carry the stone between them, with the bush behind them. 1992. Photo: family collection

Open full image

A black and white photograph of men bending over a plaque on a square base inside a concrete grave surround in the bush, while others stand and watch.
Setting the stone in place at the grave site in the bush, with family looking on. 1992. Photo: family collection

Open full image

A colour photograph of hands and arms around a plaque for Charles and Elizabeth Huntley on a white base set into fresh earth and grass.
Hands settle the plaque onto its base at the grave site. 1992. Photo: family collection

Open full image

A colour photograph of a shingle beach under thick bush, with a low dry-stone wall, people standing on the beach and the bank, a yellow dinghy on the grass and calm water in front.
Family on the beach below the bush and the old stone wall, on the 1992 reunion weekend. Photo: family collection

Open full image

A colour photograph of a crowd on a shingle beach beside a carved waka at the water's edge, with a red-hulled launch, a dinghy and buildings behind, under bush.
The waka pulled up on the beach, with family gathered along the shore at the 1992 reunion. Photo: family collection

Open full image

A black and white photograph of men carrying a stone slab along a bush track behind a man in white robes and a woman holding a bowl, with a crowd beside a stone wall and a dinghy in the foreground.
The stone is carried up through the bush, led by a man in church robes and a woman carrying a bowl, with family gathered alongside. 1992. Photo: family collection

Open full image

A colour photograph of three older men standing arm in arm, wearing name tags, above a wooden plaque that names them.
Charles (Smoks), Cairo and Ossie Huntley, the only surviving grandsons of Charles and Elizabeth, the three sons of William and Hariata Huntley. Photo: family collection

Open full image

◆

Sources from the original post

Where this one comes from. Most of it is our own family's papers, and the story says whose memory each part is.

1. October 1911. Mum copied it out by hand, three pages the family holds, from D. M. Furness, Tahuahua: The Story of Blackwood Bay, Queen Charlotte Sound (WorldCat OCLC 153715574). The story quotes the book only for "the black month". The passage is also on the Our story page of her website.
https://shelteredwater.com/story

2. Annie Woodgate's death. "Personal", Marlborough Express, 12 October 1911, page 4: the death at Picton hospital on the Tuesday morning of Mrs Woodgate of Blackwood Bay, admitted on the Sunday evening with pneumonia, leaving a husband and eleven children, the youngest five days old.
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/MEX19111012.2.17

3. The death index. The New Zealand Births, Deaths and Marriages historical index has all four: Annie Woodgate, 1911/8309, aged 38. Elizabeth Huntley, 1911/8310. William Thomas Woodgate, 1911/8311, aged 18. Charles Huntley, 1911/8313. The certificates themselves haven't been read for this story.
https://www.bdmhistoricalrecords.dia.govt.nz/

4. The rest of the bay. "Education Board", Marlborough Express, 14 November 1911, under Tahuahua: a letter from the bay reporting another death, and three children of another family in hospital. "Marlborough Schools", Marlborough Express, 3 May 1911, for the new school at Tahuahua put up in 1910.
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/MEX19111114.2.21
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/MEX19110503.2.6

5. Allan. "Personal", Marlborough Express, 26 September 1912: Allan Huntley, brought up to Picton from Blackwood Bay the week before with rheumatic fever, died at the hospital on the Monday evening, aged 20, the fourth son of the late Captain Huntley.
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/MEX19120926.2.13

6. The boat in 1905. "Supposed Boating Fatality", Marlborough Express, 18 January 1905, and "The Boating Accident", 19 January 1905: two young men named Huntley left Picton about 10 o'clock at night for Blackwood Bay, their boat was found bottom up off Dieffenbach with all its sails set, and they swam for over half an hour to the shore. The second report calls them sons of Mr C. Huntley of Blackwood Bay, says that part of the Sound "is noted for the choppy nature of its water", and says the goods they had for the homestead were lost.
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/MEX19050118.2.23
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/MEX19050119.2.5

7. How far. Ellesmere Guardian, 3 May 1938 ("Little Rakaia" column): "Blackwood Bay, a resort in the Sounds about 11 miles from Picton".
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/EG19380503.2.14.3

8. Jean's memories, and Peti's family. Mike Taylor of the Picton Museum, "John McDonald of Waitohi", a research paper he compiled after working on this history with the late Kaumātua Frank MacDonald. On pages 4 and 5, Mrs Gwen Matthews gives on 21 July 1986 what Annie's daughter Jean told her: her gran's very curly hair, the feathered cloak, the raupō whare with cloaks on the floor to sleep in, and her gran speaking over the water while her husband came up the Sound in his sailing boat. Taylor's own research has John McDonald as "the first pakeha to settle in Waitohi (Picton)" (page 1) and "the whaler and first white man at Waitohi" (page 5), and his wife as a native of Waitohi Pā (page 4). His footnote 7 says Elizabeth McDonald was also known as Irihapeti, or Peti, and page 4 has her marrying Harry Aldridge, son of Michael Aldridge, before she married Charles Huntley. Peti's parents, John McDonald and Takaroa Makutu, are from Mum and from the family chart on page 22 of our 2010 reunion book. Page 9 of her October 1992 reunion book, Descendants of Charles-Elizabeth Huntley, also names Takaroa Makutu as Peti's mother. The sources differ in two places. Page 9 of the 1992 book gives Takaroa's husband as George O'Donnell, and Taylor names John McDonald's wife as Hematini Te Puku (page 5).

9. Auntie Phoebe. Our family reunion book, page 117, written by Mum from hours of talking with Phoebe Huntley. Mum drove from Picton to Motueka with family and spent the day with her (Mum's handwritten answer, 14 November 2026). The page covers the burning on the beach the day Charles was buried, her Uncle Allan rowing her and her brother Donald in a dinghy while her parents and grandparents had the flu, and her memory of her Granny. The same page names Charles Huntley as her father William's father.

10. The stone and the waka. Read from the photographs on one page of our reunion book of 2 April 2010, The Descendants of Charles Aldridge and Hariata (Noti) Kere/Kelly, compiled by Mum and her sister. The stone reads "In Memory Of Charles & Elizabeth Huntley", with their years, "And their descendants Aldridge & Woodgate Families. Erected by Committee Members of Huntley Reunion 1992." The two headstones, one that stayed at the Waikawa urupā and one taken by waka to Blackwood Bay on the reunion weekend, are from Mum's own handwritten answer of 14 November 2026, a family account.

11. Mum's sixty feet. Her own account is on the Our story page of her website, linked above.

12. For the times. Pneumonia in 1911: The New Zealand Official Year-Book, 1912, Vital Statistics, "Causes of Death": "There were 522 deaths in 1911, against 448 in 1910." Penicillin's first use in New Zealand: "First Use in N.Z.", Evening Post, 24 March 1944. Raupō as the bulrush used for building: Te Aka Māori Dictionary.
https://www3.stats.govt.nz/New_Zealand_Official_Yearbooks/1912/NZOYB_1912.html
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/EP19440324.2.92
https://maoridictionary.co.nz/search?keywords=raupo#d7872

13. The family line. The earlier stories carry their own sources. The Old Whaler and the Bishop, for Michael Aldridge at Ocean Bay. The Chair That Never Came Home, for Hariata and the chair. The Shark Man of Fishing Bay, for Ossie.
https://shelteredwater.com/story-the-old-whaler-and-the-bishop.html
https://shelteredwater.com/story-the-chair-that-never-came-home.html
https://shelteredwater.com/story-the-shark-man-of-fishing-bay.html

A note on names. The McDonald name is written McDonald, MacDonald, McDonnell, O'Donnell and O'Donald in different records, and Mum writes O'Donnell / McDonald. Thomas junior is in the index as William Thomas Woodgate. Auntie Phoebe's page spells Allan as Alan. Any pictures with this post are dated and checked on their own.